The current AgentLocator site already displays client review content, a real trust asset. Separately, as of August 4, Ahrefs could not find the current .com or .ca site in Canadian Google searches at all: zero keywords, zero estimated visits.
That is a search baseline, not proof that the website or Google Business Profile failed to create leads. Search Console, Analytics and CRM data are required to confirm actual impressions, clicks, indexed URLs and conversions.
AgentLocator may also contain useful listing search, saved searches, contacts and automations. The responsible move is to measure what it produces, preserve useful assets and choose the architecture after the evidence is collected.
The payoff: keep the trust you have already earned, put it behind a clearer seller-first website where every inquiry can be counted, and throw away nothing useful in AgentLocator along the way.